Is Posada Hall of fame material

Stop! I got some stats. I would like your comments on this one.  Me and an old friend were chatting last night and he told me Jorge was a bum! I know he loves Posada he bleeds pinstripes. Well old friend here is the stats of the best hall of fame catchers and of Posada's . Let the fans decide. Let your voice be heard leave a comment! I will get back to this topic.
http://www.baseball-almanac.com

Catchers BOLD Indicates Statistical Leader For HOF Catchers Name [Link To Full Stats] AVG OBP SLG HITS HR RBI RUNS SB Johnny Bench .267 .345 .476 2,048 389 1,376 1,091 68 Yogi Berra .285 .350 .482 2,150 358 1,430 1,175 30 Roger Bresnahan .279 .386 .377 1,252 26 530 682 212 Roy Campanella .276 .362 .500 1,161 242 856 627 25 Gary Carter .262 .335 .439 2,092 324 1,225 1,025 39 Mickey Cochrane .320 .419 .478 1,652 119 832 1,041 64 Bill Dickey .313 .382 .486 1,969 202 1,209 930 36 Buck Ewing .303 .351 .456 1,625 71 883 1,129 354 Rick Ferrell .281 .378 .363 1,692 28 734 687 29 Carlton Fisk .269 .343 .457 2,356 376 1,330 1,276 128 Gabby Hartnett .297 .370 .489 1,912 236 1,179 867 28 Ernie Lombardi .306 .358 .460 1,792 190 990 601 8 Ray Schalk .253 .340 .316 1,345 11 594 579 177 Name [Link To Full Stats] AVG OBP SLG HITS HR RBI RUNS SB Hall of Fame Catchers

Jorge 

Posada

http://www.baseball-reference.com

Standard Batting

More Stats

 Glossary  · SHARE  · CSV  · PRE  · LINK  · More Tools

• Minors
• Game Logs [+]
• Splits [+]
• HR Log
• vs. Pitcher
• Finders [+]

Year	Age	Tm	Lg	G	PA	AB	R	H	2B	3B	HR	RBI	SB	CS	BB	SO	BA	OBP	SLG	OPS	OPS+	TB	GDP	HBP	SH	SF	IBB	Pos	Awards
1995	23	NYY	AL	1	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0						0	0	0	0	0	0	/2
1996	24	NYY	AL	8	15	14	1	1	0	0	0	0	0	0	1	6	.071	.133	.071	.205	-46	1	1	0	0	0	0	/2
1997	25	NYY	AL	60	224	188	29	47	12	0	6	25	1	2	30	33	.250	.359	.410	.768	101	77	2	3	1	2	2	2
1998	26	NYY	AL	111	409	358	56	96	23	0	17	63	0	1	47	92	.268	.350	.475	.824	115	170	14	0	0	4	7	2/D3
1999	27	NYY	AL	112	437	379	50	93	19	2	12	57	1	0	53	91	.245	.341	.401	.742	91	152	9	3	0	2	2	*2/3D
2000	28	NYY	AL	151	624	505	92	145	35	1	28	86	2	2	107	151	.287	.417	.527	.943	139	266	11	8	0	4	10	*23/D	AS,SS
2001	29	NYY	AL	138	557	484	59	134	28	1	22	95	2	6	62	132	.277	.363	.475	.838	117	230	10	6	0	5	10	*2/D3	AS,SS
2002	30	NYY	AL	143	598	511	79	137	40	1	20	99	1	0	81	143	.268	.370	.468	.837	121	239	23	3	0	3	9	*2/D	AS,SS
2003	31	NYY	AL	142	588	481	83	135	24	0	30	101	2	4	93	110	.281	.405	.518	.922	144	249	13	10	0	4	6	*2/D	AS,MVP-3,SS
2004	32	NYY	AL	137	547	449	72	122	31	0	21	81	1	3	88	92	.272	.400	.481	.881	131	216	24	9	0	1	5	*2
2005	33	NYY	AL	142	546	474	67	124	23	0	19	71	1	0	66	94	.262	.352	.430	.782	109	204	8	2	0	4	5	*2/D
2006	34	NYY	AL	143	545	465	65	129	27	2	23	93	3	0	64	97	.277	.374	.492	.867	122	229	10	11	0	5	1	*2/D3
2007	35	NYY	AL	144	589	506	91	171	42	1	20	90	2	0	74	98	.338	.426	.543	.970	153	275	18	6	0	3	7	*2/D3	AS,MVP-6,SS
2008	36	NYY	AL	51	195	168	18	45	13	1	3	22	0	0	24	38	.268	.364	.411	.775	103	69	7	2	0	1	3	2D/3
2009	37	NYY	AL	111	438	383	55	109	25	0	22	81	1	0	48	101	.285	.363	.522	.885	125	200	13	2	0	5	4	2/D3
2010	38	NYY	AL	120	451	383	49	95	23	1	18	57	3	1	59	99	.248	.357	.454	.811	116	174	6	7	0	2	3	2D/3
2011	39	NYY	AL	4	16	14	4	4	0	0	3	6	0	0	2	1	.286	.375	.929	1.304	215	13	0	0	0	0	0	*/D
17 Seasons				1718	6779	5762	870	1587	365	10	264	1027	20	19	899	1378	.275	.377	.480	.857	123	2764	169	72	1	45	74
162 Game Avg.				162	639	543	82	150	34	1	25	97	2	2	85	130	.275	.377	.480	.857	123	261	16	7	0	4	7
				G	PA	AB	R	H	2B	3B	HR	RBI	SB	CS	BB	SO	BA	OBP	SLG	OPS	OPS+	TB	GDP	HBP	SH	SF	IBB	Pos	Awards